Thomas Aquinas asks 'Is God Self-Evident?' Or, Why Bother Proving God's Existence? (Part 1 of 3)
Why bother proving God's existence, especially if you already believe in God and think God is self-evident? Saint Thomas Aquinas argues in his Summa Theologica (Part I, Question 2, Article 1) that it's good for Christians to have reasons to believe - against some serious objections. This video sets up Aquinas' Cosmological Argument, as given in his 5 Ways to Prove God's Existence. This is part 1 of 3 videos in this series.
0:00 Introduction - Belief with Reason
2:54 Tyson Objects with Science
7:31 Why Bother?
8:51 What Self-evident Means
11:23 Self-evident and to Us
12:17 Self-evident but not to Us
14:03 Is God Self-evident?
15:33 Objection 1: All Know God
16:41Objection 2: The Ontological Argument
19:58 Conclusion
Don't miss the other 2 videos in this series:
Video 2 (Question 2, article 2) Can Philosophy Actually Prove God's Existence? Or, can God's existence be demonstrated? https://youtu.be/FMOCFzc7fvQ
Video 3 (Question 2, article 3) How Aquinas Proves God's Existence https://youtu.be/WE18DL8gAwo
I hope people find this video series helpful, but honestly - everyone should read Aquinas for yourself. To understand the Five Ways you have to start here, in Part 1, Question 2, Article 1 of the Summa Theologica: https://www.newadvent.org/summa/1002.htm#article1
Aquinas believes that reason strengthens one's faith, and he argues that God's existence is self-evident, but not everyone understand that point. Why's that? Because only those who actually understand the nature of God properly understand that God is self-evident. To be clear, believers don't need to understand God's existence is self-evident to believe, but such knowledge actually helps their faith. And atheists who deny God's existence is self-evident aren't proving God doesn't exist. They are just explaining that they don't understand what God is, which is completely understandable since they don't believe God exists. The actual proofs come later (article 3/Video 3). But for now, in this video, Aquinas is simply arguing that philosophical arguments can explain God's nature, and such arguments can strengthen one's faith. Now if you don't think God's existence is self-evident, great. This video is for you!
Aquinas, of course, considers several objections to his argument. A cartoon Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson argues Aquinas is wasting his time, since science has found no evidence for God. A modern anthropologist argues everyone naturally has knowledge of the Divine. And St. Anselm of Canterbury argues everyone can easily know that God exists thanks to his Ontological Argument. But no surprise, St. Thomas responds!
I really respect Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson, and he's said just about everything his cartoon version says in the video. Here are a few examples on YouTube. Take a look!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I0nXG02tpDw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXAokvnv7Mc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8eoX9eu1_Rw
I look forward to reading your comments on this video. Did Aquinas convince you that true faith seeks understanding? If not, where do you think the argument falls apart?
Are you interested in the 5 Ways and the Cosmological Arguments? Great! The next 2 videos in this series address these topics and match up with Aquinas' next 2 articles. Don't miss them!
This video was made with #characteranimator, along with Adobe's Illustrator, Audition and Premiere Pro. What a great suite of programs!
#Philosophy, #Aquinas
#Comments
YOU NEED TO LOGIN IN ORDER TO COMMENT